Which Mattress Is Best Spring Or Foam?

When considering which mattress is best for you – spring or foam – it fundamentally comes down to personal preference and specific needs. Spring mattresses, known for their bounciness and strong support, are traditionally favored for their durability. Foam mattresses, on the other hand, are appreciated for their pressure-relieving qualities and ability to contour to the body. Each has distinctive benefits and potential drawbacks, and the best choice will depend on individual comfort preferences, sleeping habits, and health considerations.

Understanding Spring Mattresses

The Classic Innerspring Mattress

Spring mattresses, perhaps the most traditional form of a mattress, are constructed with a system of interconnected or individually pocketed coils. These coils are designed to offer support and to distribute your weight evenly across the bed. Traditionally, the more coils a mattress contains, the better support it can provide.

One key advantage of spring mattresses is their breathability. The space between the springs allows for good air circulation, which helps to keep the mattress cool. This is a significant benefit for those who tend to sleep hot. Additionally, spring mattresses usually have a firmer surface, which some sleepers prefer, especially those who sleep on their back or stomach because it can offer better support and help maintain a neutral spine alignment.

Variations of Spring Mattresses

Spring mattresses have evolved, and variations now include models with pocketed coils that move independently to reduce motion transfer—a benefit if you sleep with a partner. Plus, many spring mattresses now include layers of foam or other materials atop the coils to provide additional comfort and cushioning.

Potential Downsides of Spring Mattresses

One downside of spring mattresses is that they can sometimes be noisy, as the springs can squeak with age and use. Moreover, they may not offer the same level of pressure relief as foam mattresses, which can be a drawback for those with joint pain or who prefer a softer, more enveloping feel.

Delving into Foam Mattresses

The Variety of Foam Mattresses

Foam mattresses include a vast range of options, such as memory foam, latex foam, and polyurethane foam. Memory foam, in particular, is renowned for its ability to conform to the body, providing excellent pressure relief and reducing motion transfer. It cradles the body’s curves, supporting areas like the hips and shoulders, which can be beneficial for side sleepers or those with pressure point pain.

Latex foam is another popular choice, known for its resilience and natural cooling properties. It’s also hypoallergenic, making it an excellent option for allergy sufferers. Polyurethane foams are generally used as a base for many foam mattresses, providing a supportive core.

Heat Retention and Response Time

However, traditional memory foam has a reputation for retaining heat, which can be uncomfortable for hot sleepers. Many foam mattress manufacturers have addressed this concern by adding cooling technologies, such as gel infusions or open-cell constructions, to help regulate temperature. Additionally, some sleepers dislike the slow response time of traditional memory foam, which can make changing positions a bit challenging, though newer formulations have improved on this aspect.

Durability and Firmness Levels

Generally, foam mattresses have a good lifespan, with high-density foams typically lasting longer than low-density alternatives. They come in various firmness levels, from very soft to firm, providing a broad range of choices to accommodate different sleeping positions and preferences.

Comparing Spring and Foam Mattresses

Support and Comfort

When looking at support, spring mattresses are often more supportive and have a better edge support compared to foam mattresses, which is something to consider if you sit on the edge of the bed frequently. Foam mattresses provide a different type of support that contours and molds to your body, which can be perceived as less supportive by some, especially if they are used to the traditional feel of a spring mattress.

Motion Isolation and Noise

In terms of isolating motion, foam mattresses typically outperform spring mattresses, especially those with individually wrapped coils. This means that if one partner moves during the night, the other is less likely to be disturbed on a foam mattress. Noise is another factor to consider, as foam mattresses are virtually silent when bearing weight, unlike some spring models that can squeak over time.

Price Considerations

From a price perspective, spring mattresses can often be less expensive than high-quality foam mattresses. However, prices vary widely based on the brand, materials, and construction quality. It’s possible to find both spring and foam mattresses across a broad range of price points, suited to budget-minded shoppers as well as those looking to invest in a luxury model.

Allergies and Health Considerations

For allergy sufferers, foam mattresses, particularly those with dense structures like memory foam, may offer some relief as they are less likely to harbor dust mites than spring mattresses. That said, natural latex mattresses are also hypoallergenic and could be an even better choice for allergy-prone individuals.

Who Might Choose Spring Over Foam?

Some people may prefer spring mattresses over foam for various reasons. Those who like a bouncy or more traditional mattress feel, sleep very hot, or require stronger edge support may lean towards a spring mattress. Also, individuals who find it difficult to get in and out of bed might appreciate the firmness and lift provided by a spring system.

Who Might Choose Foam Over Spring?

Foam mattresses might be more suitable for those seeking pressure relief, couples who value motion isolation, and sleepers with specific pain points like the hips or shoulders. Additionally, memory foam fans often appreciate the hugging quality that memory foam provides. Back and side sleepers might find foam mattresses particularly comfortable, as they can offer better spinal alignment for these positions.

Top 5 Mattresses Recommended By GoodSleepHub.com

Considerations Before Making Your Choice

Before deciding on a spring or foam mattress, consider these factors:
– Body weight and preferred sleeping position
– Whether you sleep hot or cold
– Budget constraints
– Any pain or health considerations
– Longevity and durability preferences
– Maintenance and ease of care
– Environmental and health certifications, for those concerned with off-gassing and ecological impact

Finishing Thoughts

Ultimately, the choice between a spring or foam mattress is a personal one that should be made after considering your unique needs and preferences. Both types of mattresses offer different benefits, and what is best for one person might not be the best for another. It’s advisable to test various mattresses if possible, read reviews, inquire about sleep trials, and check the warranty before making a decision. With the right mattress, you’re positioning yourself for a better night’s sleep, which can have a significant impact on your overall health and well-being. Remember that choosing a mattress is an investment in your sleep quality, so take the time to select the one that truly meets your needs.


  • Ashton Roberts

    I love learning and sharing everything about sleep. I am one of the energetic editors here at GoodSleepHub, where I talk about how to get a better night's sleep. When I'm not writing, I'm probably walking my dog Luna or trying out new sleeping gadgets. My goal is to help you sleep easier and better. Join me, and let's find simple ways to enjoy great sleep every night!

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Good Sleep Hub